Industry: water, steel & energy
Gronow, Colin (9 of 9). An Oral History of the Electricity Supply in the UK
The British Library Board acknowledges the intellectual property rights of those named as contributors to this recording and the rights of those not identified.
Legal and ethical usage »
2014-10-22, 2014-10-18, 2014-12-16, 2015-01-36
Gronow, Colin, 1929- (speaker, male)
Lean, Thomas (speaker, male)
Part 9: Remarks on senior colleagues at Electricity Council: Ray Orson, Central Member for finance and commercial matters; Duncan McGruther in charge of secretarial matters; chairman Francis Tombs followed by former civil servant Philip Jones, earlier connected with Concorde; Alan Plumpton, deputy chairman, until resigning after being passed over for chairmanship by Philip Jones; David Jefferies' [deputy] chairman; intimidating one-legged deputy chairman Austin Bunch; anecdote about Bunch bullying Orson; [04:45] anecdote about Bunch intimidating CG after CG objected to Bunch being rude to Glyn England; mentions Francis Tombs finding Bunch good value; anecdote about Tombs kicking Austin in artificial leg; anecdote about Austin Bunch being promoted to Chairman by Nigel Lawson for only one year; anecdote about Bunch's knighthood; [08:10] Philip Jones a typical civil servant with limited understanding of ESI; CG finding David Jefferies firm but easy to work for. [09:40] Story about CG thwarted 'Budget Warmth' scheme for supplying elderly with unmetered storage heaters: political concern about elderly cold in winter; CG solution of unmetered flat tariff storage heater remote controlled by area control according to need and paid for over whole year; CG seeing use of radio signals to control heaters in Switzerland; half Area Board chairman alarmed at idea of unmetered supplies, David Jefferies unduly objecting to scheme due to concerns it would add to ongoing meter tampering problem; anecdote about Jefferies concern over extent of engineering knowledge. [15:15] Remarks on: CG lacking engineering background but respecting the limits of his understanding and getting on well with engineers, mentions earlier experience in Scotland. [17:25] Comments on CG responsibilities as Central Member for Engineering, Marketing and Research: limited knowledge of engineering, but wide experience of marketing and research; subordinate managers, Engineering Adviser Frank Davenport, marketing adviser Jack Taylor, and Commercial Adverser Terry Boley; Trevor Churchman in charge of research, Matt Cowan joint manager of Capenhurst research centre, long friendship with CG; anecdote about CG visiting all 12 Area Boards when he started the job, Area Boards' disinterest in Electricity Council help; [21:30] anecdote about Frank Davenport concern over future of distribution system leading to impossibly enormous meeting of Area Board chief engineers, CG solution of pairing Boards up to investigate issues; Area Boards all independent entities with their own responsibilities; CG becoming Central Member on recommendation of Francis Tombs, CG feelings about post, 5 year contract but retiring a year early; clarification of date Francis Tombs was chairman, dates of CG appointments at Electricity Council [marketing Adviser 1978, Commercial Adviser 1980, Central Member 1985-90]. [27:50] Remarks on industry research: CG chairing industry research committee including CEGB's Derek Davis and Area Board chairmen; anecdote about difficulty judging CEGB research programme; difficulty justifying expense of Capenhurst leading to comparative exercise with other industries, anecdote about CG speech to EDF in Paris; Trevor Churchman's research into heated greenhouses and other areas aimed at applications; Area Boards concerns over costs of Capenhurst, difficulty for CG to judge economics of Capenhurst; [33:35] CG visit to American equivalent of Capenhurst; estimate of size of Capenhurst. [35:10] [cont' from 35:10] Remarks on meetings of the Electricity Council: composition of Council meetings with representatives from around industry; Gil Blackman, Fred Bonner, Walter Marshall and John Baker amongst CEGB representatives; Walter Marshall and Philip Jones history of antipathy; anecdote about Marshall leaning meetings to go to Ascot races; CG friendly with Walter Marshall wife; outline of typical meeting; outer friendliness of meetings disguising Area Board dislike of Council; Area Board Chairmen delighted at privatisation freeing them Council, Chairmen declaring Council 'dead in the water'. [39:35] Remarks on privatisation: Philip Jones advocating split of transmission system from privatised CEGB, to chagrin of CEGB; split of CEGB at privatisation and entry of foreign companies into British ESI, EDF success in nuclear power; competitive profit oriented nature of current ESI. [41:30] Short story about CG turning down leadership of Office of Electricity Regulation [OFFER]: Francis Tombs offering to recommend CG for role; CG in process of retirement and move to Dorset; CG offer to do job part time unacceptable to Margaret Thatcher; anecdote about CG considering doing job if it came with a knighthood; anecdote about Francis Tombs and Margaret Thatcher. [44:00] Comments on privatisation: CG not thinking it was a bad idea; CG view that CEGB was inefficient, more generation than needed, poor record in completing nuclear stations; advantages of rationalising Area Boards, which were already more efficient than CEGB; difference in attitude between CEGB and Area Boards, CEGB detached from customers compared to Area Boards; Electricity Council more efficient due to pressure from Area Boards, Area Boards week compared to CEGB; CG hoping privatisation would lower costs; [48:25] Electricity Council shattered by privatisation, staff looking for jobs around Area Boards; staff with skills outside electricity joining other companies, CG secretary becoming secretary to Derek Davis and Walter Marshall; importance of good secretary to CG work at SSEB and Council; [52:35] many staff finding jobs outside ESI; work at Council stopping after privatisation announcement, CG taking a holiday, anecdote about Philip Jones reading newspaper in his office; Roger Farrance hard work setting up Electricity Association, including Frank Davenport and Richard Savinson; Jack Taylor retiring; Terry Boley move to SEEB; anecdote about CG applying for job as NEEB chairman; set up of industry regulator with privatisation, CG decision to retire. [57:25] Remarks on retirement in 1990: CG taking 3 months holiday in Portugal before retiring, ringing secretary every Monday morning to see if anything needed doing; staff finding jobs for themselves; CG enjoying job, not staying on long enough to be awarded CBE; CG paid £65,000 salary for year contract cut short; CG and wife travelling world in retirement, such as America, Alaska and New Zealand; CG visits to Ryder Cup tournaments; time share in Tenerife, swapped with American couples for holidays in the USA, CG selling time share to avoid complications as he got older; [1:03:25] CG not doing any consultancy work in retirement, condition that he was available as consultant for Capenhurst after retirement. [1:04:10] [cont' from 1:04:10] Remarks on industry since retirement and climate change: limits of CG knowledge; politicians causing problems for ESI; false worries over global warming and carbon dioxide from power stations having detrimental effect on industry, waste of large subsidies paid to ineffective wind industry; European Union rules against coal fired power stations; France insulated from issues due to large nuclear industry, German abandonment of nuclear power leading to need to burn coal instead; large number of American, Indian and Chinese coal burning power station limiting effectiveness of cut in British carbon dioxide emissions; [Christopher] Booker 'Sunday Telegraph' column and book debunking global warming; [1:09:00] energy industry not as good as previously, misuse of gas as power station fuel; CG unsure of future of industry, current situation a mess due to government mistakes; CG suspecting that privatisation has made little difference to efficiency of ESI, but limited knowledge of current ESI; satisfactions of CG career, significance of Space Heater working party, cut to peak load, increased significance of marketing; possible change to service industry in future, in spite of price rises. [1:13:20] Remarks on interview process, importance of ESI.