Industry: water, steel & energy
Gronow, Colin (6 of 9). An Oral History of the Electricity Supply in the UK
The British Library Board acknowledges the intellectual property rights of those named as contributors to this recording and the rights of those not identified.
Legal and ethical usage »
2014-10-22, 2014-10-18, 2014-12-16, 2015-01-33
Gronow, Colin, 1929- (speaker, male)
Lean, Thomas (speaker, male)
Part 6: Remarks on work studies: management services department, run by Ben Hastings later chairman of MANWEB, running work study exercises; changes in methods to reduce manpower, taken up by other Area Boards but not CEGB; similarities with rest of UK taking up SSEB switch to marketing electricity emphasis; short description of work study applied to trench digging; CG not recalling union problems over work study; staff not made redundant from studies but reduced through not being replaced over time; spread of attitudes throughout organisation. [04:35] Remarks on tariffs: CG knowing little of area board activities before transfer to SSEB; CG expert on tariffs; national principle of not favouring one type of customer over another, tariff having to reflect costs of supply; tariffs varying according to different patterns of use; Scotland's unusual situation of favouring domestic customers in tariffs, rebalanced by CG during his time at SSEB. [07:10] Comments on long run marginal cost basis applied to tariffs by Electricity Council: outline of how short run marginal cost was dependent on extra generation required to meet demand above base load; outline of long run marginal cost, same principle of short run marginal costs projected 20-30 years in the future, requiring understanding future power stations and costs; suitability of long run marginal costs for planning a growing industry due to emphasis on extra costs required to meet demand; 7% per annum growth when CG joined the CEGB and continuing for a number of years; industry having to constantly plan for growth. [11:20] Description of how ESI earning levels were calculated: government setting earning as a percentage return on cost of assets employed; ESI required to adjust earnings levels in future years if excess profits made; averaging out of profits over a few years; much work in accurately forecasting demand; CG leading groups involved in overseeing tariff and forecasting growth and revenue. [15:10] Remarks on: outline of CG subordinate small groups working on tariffs, forecasting and research; complexity of long run marginal costs and approximation of results; differences in generation type effecting economics of marginal costing, example of nuclear power stations having high capital costs but low running costs; forecasting based on growth rate of system, power station construction programme, distribution and transmission costs; [19:15] principle of not varying costs for different customers a result of lack of competition in electricity; SSEB favouring domestic over industrial customers; varying of industrial tariffs with changes to fuel prices, unlike domestic customers; CG balancing domestic and industrial customers tariffs by capping fuel price linked increases for industrial customers; CG believing that nobody deserved preferential treatment. [23:30] Remarks on negotiations at Scottish Office over forecasting: industry costs dependent on CG forecasts; annual civil service scrutiny of figures and finances. [25:50] Story about CG renegotiations over costs of electricity from British Nuclear Fuels Limited [BNFL] Chapelcross nuclear power station: Chapelcross electricity price linked to price of coal; CG asked to renegotiate deal; BNFL two years of stubbornness over renegotiation; anecdote about CG threat to stop taking electricity from Chapelcross, a bluff which resolved situation; outline of new arrangements for costs; large saving for SSEB.[30:35] [cont' from 30:35] Remarks on negotiations with North of Scotland Hydro Electric Board [NSHEB]: NSHEB and SSEB joint energy pool; NSHEB valuing hydroelectric units more highly than from other sources due to limits on its use; issue referred to Sir Norman Elliott at Electricity Council for arbitration; anecdote about Elliott asking for CG suggestions for resolving situation, which were adopted as the solution; anecdote about Norman Elliott favouring short reports; reduction on value of hydroelectric units. [34:55] Story about attempt to reform costs of interconnection between SSEB and CEGB transmission systems: swapping of cost information between control rooms and import or export of power according to cheapest generation available; CEGB view that SSEB should pay more of the capital costs of system, costed according to position of border; CEGB view that SSEB should pay more as they imported more electricity; small amount of money involved in dispute; CG discovering that SSEB frequently exported maximum 200MW interconnection was capable of carrying; correctness of CG suggestion of halving of costs of transmission system accepted by CEGB negotiator; anecdote about CG attempt to obtain backdated costs from CEGB, resulting in indignant letter from CEGB financial director Fred Bonner; situation eventually remaining unchanged; CG enjoyment of negotiations. [42:10] Story about CG creative resolution of problems with pricing of electricity for new aluminium plant: prime minister Harold Wilson's grand schemes for aluminium plants in Wales and Scotland; 200MW constant demand of aluminium plants; Aluminium plant demand for lower electricity costs incompatible with principle of equal prices for all customers; CEGB immune from equal costs rule in supplying electricity to similar plant in North Wales; CG discussions with SSEB financial officer Willie McKay; solution found of selling British Aluminium part of Hunterston B nuclear power station to provide them cheaper electricity without selling it to them at a lower cost; interim solution of providing electricity priced at short run marginal costs, whilst Hunterston built. [49:20] Remarks on: CG work sometimes involving special cases; aluminium smelter solution working well; CEGB solution for supplying energy from Wylfa to aluminium plant; varying level of contact between CG and CEGB. [52:20] Remarks on miners strikes: CG discussions with CEGB over how Area Boards would manage rota disconnections; clarification of Edward Heath problems with miners strike in 1970s and Margaret Thatcher in 1980s; anecdote about eating in restaurants when power cut off at home; CG talking to customers; customers accepting situation; demands of miners and Arthur Scargill in 1980s foiled by CEGB response coordinated by Gil Blackman and Frank Ledger. [57:10] Remarks on overseas conferences and international bodies: CG travel to Spain, Poland, Turkey, Austria, Yugoslavia and Canada; need to provide report on conference on return; anecdote about Francis Tombs asking CG to enjoying himself on a conference; mentions CG and Francis Tombs visits to Austrian Opera; anecdote about running across Arthur Hawkins at a conference; use of interpreters in conferences; conferences tending to allow less developed countries to learn from more developed ones; Francis Tombs having a sense of humour in spite of austere reputation. [1:01:25] [cont' from 1:01:25] Remarks on golf: SSEB golf day; several golfers amongst senior staff including Christensen and John Lardner; annual golf matches against gas board and other organisations; CG instigating golf day between head office and area staff to build relations. [1:03:50] Remarks on CG interaction with other groups at SSEB: close interaction between senior staff through weekly management meetings of chief officers of different areas, staff encouraged to comment on different areas of business; example of CG providing economic predictions for proposed schemes being planned, occasional need for customers to contribute to costs of schemes. [1:07:10] Remarks on CG placement as District Manager: Francis Tombs suggesting CG needed field experience; CG 9 months at large Glasgow North District, reporting to area manager; CG management team with people from commercial, accounts and engineering; learning experience for CG; benefits of understanding staff in field better; anecdote about bomb scare. [1:11:30] Story about work study in Glasgow North area: work study suggesting that a work group should be reduced; CG suggestion that older member of staff who made the tea should be moved; union representative Featherstonhaugh and other staff offering to pay wages of extra staff member; CG pretending to reassess study so that so older worker could stay on. [1:15:35] Story about CG organising study into meter tampering: concentration of tampering in Glasgow; program of checking seals and resealing of meters around SSEB; Francis Tombs instigating investigation. [1:19:10] Remarks on management team in Glasgow North district.