Oral history of British science
Cottrell, Alan (Part 1 of 1). An Oral History of British Science.
The British Library Board acknowledges the intellectual property rights of those named as contributors to this recording and the rights of those not identified.
Legal and ethical usage »
Interviewees home, Cambridge.
Cottrell, Alan, 1919-2012 (speaker, male)
Lean, Thomas (speaker, male)
Part 1: Remarks on youth: inheritances from parents; being a dreamy child at school but winning prizes; hobbies, including Meccano, models, chemistry and electrical sets; 1936 scholarship to Birmingham University, persuaded into metallurgy by Professor Hanson; interests at University, sports, exercise, bridge, music; graduation in 1939. [02:45] Remarks on: parents, father interested in engineering, mother interested in music, keen on education, father property manager; interest in Meccano; anecdote about his dreamy nature almost getting him into trouble at school; being advised against physics at university by a school master; limited knowledge of metallurgy, before being persuaded into it by Professor Hanson; university; [07:00] tried to join army at start of war, but sent back to university. Discussion about wartime research: description of how arc welding made tank armour brittle; AC becoming an expert welder; description of armour experiments; feelings about being a scientists in wartime, feeling he owed something to country; colleagues; work on Admiralty bronzes and on Merlin engine cylinders; indirect contact with military. [13:55] Remarks on: hobbies outside work, bridge, music, hill walking; Professor Hanson asking him to form a new lecture course on atomic science of metals; difference between atomic science of metals and previous approaches to metallurgy. [17:20] Remarks on postwar work on plastic properties of metals: crystal dislocations; working with Cambridge researcher Robert Cahn, whose experimental work tied in with AC's theoretical work; election to Royal Society in 1955 for work on dislocations in steel; primitive laboratory facilities at Birmingham, laboratory workshops. [21:16] Remarks on: meeting wife Jean at Birmingham Iron and Steel institute, marrying in 1944; son Geoffrey, a scientist at Culham, and adopted daughter Johanna, a nurse. [22:55] Comments on Atomic Energy Research Establishment Harwell: invited to join in 1955; description of a problem he discovered with the Magnox nuclear reactor design; description of experiment, irradiating a spring on a fishing wire and measuring via a theodolite; views on nuclear power; [26:55] AC forming a research group to investigate if Magnox reactors could have similar problems to those which caused 1957 Windscale Fire; experimental arrangements to ascertain safety of Magnox reactors; freedom to think; [30:23] differences between being being a government and academic scientist, finding Harwell tougher atmosphere than Birmingham, but work satisfying; small team; national importance of work; invited to join AERE by Monty Finniston. [33:25] Comments on Cambridge: invited to chair of metallurgy in 1958; need to modernise department; teaching from atomic perspective; new staff, [Anthony] Kelly, Robin Nicholson, Jim Charles; electron microscope, with support from Atomic Energy Agency and Electricity Generating Board; electron microscopy, worked on by Robin Nicholson, use in seeing dislocations; superconductivity research. [38:22] Fibre strengthening work with Anthony Kelly, basic theory of strong fibres leading to materials such as Carbon Fibre; anecdote about advising Edward Heath to use carbon fibre on his boat; connection of academic work with applications of it, importance of Jim Charles' industrial background; relevance of understanding metals from atomic point of view, with reference to high temperature alloys in jet engines; colleagues, such as Bruce Bilby at Sheffield; becoming more of a theoretician over the years, link of theory and experimental work; happiest parts of work; enjoying teaching; [45:00] other head of department duties; remaining on various government scientific advisory committees, such as board of AEA. [46:40] Remarks on Whitehall: feeling British industry needed more scientific input; Sir Solly Zuckerman and Lord Louis Mountbatten inviting him to Whitehall; work on Denis Healey defence review, with reference to East of Suez and aircraft carriers; AC becoming Zuckerman's deputy when he became Chief Scientific Advisor [CSA]; overview of issues worked on, including brain drain, space research, Concorde, Advanced Passenger Train, Torrey Canyon disaster; AC becoming CSA after Zuckerman's retirement; complications of overlap of CSA responsibility with Victor Rothschild's Central Policy Review Staff [CPRS]; difficulties between Government research councils and Rothschild, AC's suggested solution leading to customer-contractor principle. [52:35] Remarks on: benefits of customer contractor principle, maintaining independence of research councils, important to attract bright scientists; returning to Cambridge in 1974 as master of Jesus College. [54:10] Further remarks on time in Whitehall: anecdote about Mountbatten approaching him at a Cambridge feast; believing industry needed more scientific management to keep up with foreign competition; realising that Harold Wilson was just using the White Hot Technological Revolution as political capital; AC relations with Zuckerman; Zuckerman's anti-nuclear weapons stance; hopes to switch funding from defence to civil research, which were thwarted by Treasury; [58:40] AC opposition to campaign for a Minister for Science; chief scientific advisor duties; AC opposed to uneconomic 'glamorous' projects such as space research and Concorde, but losing to Tony Benn on Concorde; AC opposition to rocketry in favour of communication satellites, reactions of industry; [1:03:10] Travelling abroad frequently, such as for NATO science committee; working life; difficulties with Rothschild; links with Lord Jellicoe; helping Margaret Thatcher with speeches on science; views of public understanding of science, working with classically educated civil servants who were fearful of science. [1:07:30] Further remarks on reorganisation of scientific civil service, AC in favour of research council independence. Remarks on politicians and science: Dennis Healey's good understanding of scientific matters, Harold Wilson, Edward Heath, Margaret Thatcher, Tony Benn. [1:11:20] Remarks on: believing in importance of economic purpose of science; high quality of pharmaceutical industry; contrast of academic and government science; frustrations of working in Whitehall. [1:14:50] Remarks on return to Cambridge: wife Jean enjoying college life; duties revising college statutes and preparing for admission of women, Lisa Jardine first female fellow; retirement research interests in metal plasticity and creep, after earlier work by Professor Andrade. [1:17:50] Remarks on: postwar material science, importance of electronic materials, changes in equipment; admission of Prince Edward as an undergraduate; enjoying undergraduate student activities; becoming Vice Chancellor of Cambridge in 1977, role mainly solving small disputes and official entertaining, such as of chancellor Prince Philip; university and government advisory committees, working with Rolls Royce. [1:23:05] Remarks on: students, John Knott, later supervisor of Julia King, and Trevor Churchman; being happiest doing academic work; mix of university and non-university roles, benefits in broadening outlook and developing contacts; approaching retirement, returning to research work in metallurgy; hobbies, enjoying music, playing the piano, until he became deaf, trout fishing; religion; [1:29:00] politics, being slightly right of centre; regarding work at Harwell and establishing reality of dislocations as his most important work; reasons for enjoying theoretical side of work most; current research work on a plasticity problem; [1:32:40] thoughts on interview; enjoying reading ancient history and modern physics; considering himself a physicist in some respects.
Interview with Sir Alan Cottrell, Metallurgist, Physicist and Chief Scientific Adviser to HM Government (1971 - 1974).
Cottrell, Alan (Part 1 of 1). An Oral History of British Science.
Please log in to update your playlists.
Can you tell us more about the context of the recording? Or can you share information on its content - timings of key sections or important details? Please add your notes. Uninformative entries may not be retained.
Please log in to leave notes.