Oral history of British science

Charnley, John (Part 16 of 23)

  • Add a note
    Log in to add a note at the bottom of this page.
  • All notes
  • My notes
  • Hide notes
Please click to leave a note

The British Library Board acknowledges the intellectual property rights of those named as contributors to this recording and the rights of those not identified.
Legal and ethical usage »

Tags (top 25):
(No tags found for this item)
  • Type


  • Duration


  • Shelf mark


  • Subjects

    Aeronautical Engineering

  • Recording date


  • Recording locations

    Interviewee's home, Camberley

  • Interviewees

    Charnley, John, 1922- (speaker, male)

  • Interviewers

    Lean, Thomas (speaker, male)

  • Abstract

    Part 16 [1:45:46][Interview Six: December 2 2010] Comments on move to London: JC expecting a change; conditions of Harold Wilson's White Heat of Technology; group in Tony Benn's [TB] Ministry of Technology [MINTECH] investigating civilian applications of defence technology; JC appointed Head of Research Planning under Sir George Macfarlane, with Sir Otto Clarke [OC] as permanent secretary. Story about OC telling off JC over his report writing, but apologising when he learned that JC was new; subsequent OC JC friendship; anecdote about TB's reaction. [06:18] Further comments on 18 months spent at MINTECH: JC growing awareness of civilian research, including the NPL and DSIR; outline of JC role taking defence technology developments, such as Carbon Fibre and Electronics, into civilian applications; JC support for Hovercraft, involving Fairey and Saunders-Roe and Magnetic Levitation Vehicles, involving Imperial College. [09:10] Further comments on hovercraft: work involving Maurice Brennan; civilian and military prospects for hovercraft; support of TB. Comments on fish freezing project involving an establishment at Aberdeen; JC spending a night on fishing vessel in the North Sea; scheme to process and freeze fish aboard fishing vessels.[15:10] Comments on oil platforms: hopes to interest shipbuilding industry in building offshore drilling platforms; JC visit to Newcastle; lack of interest by ship builders due to problems obtaining investment from city financiers preoccupied with short term profits; American companies building oil rigs instead; JC disappointment at attitudes of civilian industry toward government support. [20:57] Remarks on MINTECH experience: lack of certainty in market driven civilian developments, compared to military world; universities lack of interest in commercial world; JC glad to return to the better defined defence area as Deputy Controller Guided Missiles [DCGW]; differences between civilian and military worlds; [25:15] Comments on: colleagues at MINTECH, George Macfarlane, Peter Twinn, and another administrator; conditions of civilian industry not suiting JC. Comments on scientific and administrative branches of the civil service: permanent secretary Frank Cooper's opinion that more scientifically trained civil servants were needed in London; differences between administration and scientific civil service career paths; [34:26] JC, as CER, later requiring directors of establishments to have served in London so they understood how the system and resource allocation worked; opposition to scientific civil servants working at MoD in London; clarity of defence procurement process. [40:08] Comments: on scientific civil servants differences from administrators; membership of a later committee, with Frank Cooper, and few other scientists; Jim Hamilton, who began as an RAE scientist but later became permanent secretary at the Department of Education and Science. [45:55] Remarks on TB: spearhead of White Heat of Technology; successful conference on marine technology; listened to advice; did good job; department managerial arrangements; JC later closer to Michael Heseltine. [51:35] Comments on government involvement in research and development, relationship to private sector, magnetic levitation vehicles and hovercraft. [57:15] Remarks on: hovercraft, Christopher Cockerell, cushion material developed using defence technology; JC linking industry, such as Dunlop, with RAE carbon fibre experts, who had never considered sporting applications; introducing civilian and military research and development world, with reference to Robert Cockburn's instructions to JC; personally introducing industry and research establishment representatives. [1:05:51] Remarks on: Concorde work, involving Jim Hamilton, MM, and HD at different times, separate from JC's MINTECH activities; JC having no involvement with space activities at MINTECH. [1:09:42] Remarks on working at MINTECH: frustrating for JC; limited impact of new technology within MINTECH; conservative practices of Ted Lee and administrator; JC leaving to replace Basil Dickins as DCGW; JC previous chain of command from Basil Dickinson and H M Wilson, whilst JC was in charge of RAE weapons department. [1:15:30] Remarks on wife Mary's reservations over JC returning to work in defence technology, but knowing that JC enjoyed his work. [1:18:09] Comments on position as DCGW: reporting to Controller Guided Weapons and Electronics [CGWL] Cliff Cornford, who JC knew from playing cricket together and running RAE departments at the same time; organisation below JC of four directors, one from each service and one for trials, with responsibility for Woomera range; JC previous trips to Woomera; anecdote about unreliability of Monarch Britannia aircraft used for transport to Woomera; arrangements for running trials at Woomera range and industry teams involved. [1:25:37] Remarks on: JC becoming CGWL; Derek Rayner abolishing CGWL post in a reassessment of defence procurement in 1973. Remarks on JC involvement in missile procurement: naval Exocet, Sea Dart and Sea Wolf; army Shorts Blowpipe and Rapier, involving George Jefferson from BAC Stevenage; [1:30:26] RAF Sparrow, involving George Hough at De Havilland. Remarks on Exocet: possible British alternatives from De Havilland and BAC; JC ordered by Bill Cook to purchase French Exocet instead. [1:33:49] Discussion of the organisation of nuclear work: London responsibility of Bill Cook; JC later responsible for AWRE Aldermaston but not the work there; RAE involved in delivery systems but not weapons themselves; JC not involved in Chevaline; Hunting’s involvement with RAE projects. [1:38:40] Story about negotiations with the French for purchase of naval Exocet: difficult initial French negotiator, replaced by more helpful General Labrunie; impasse over electronic countermeasures [ECM] information; impasse broken after JC had coffee spilt over him at a meeting. [1:43:40] Remarks on: knowledge of Argentine Exocet capability in the Falklands war; cancellation of Hawker Siddeley air-surface weapon; considerations in designing a guided missile and consequent division of R&D activity; JC enjoying time as DCGW before promotion to CGWL. [1:46:40] Comments on Defence Procurement Board [DPB]: membership, including JC, Victor Macklen, Ewen Broadbent, Cliff Cornford. [1:50:40] Comments on: Derek Rayner's defence procurement reorganisation removing CGWL position; reassignment of CGWL work between service directors. [1:54:40] Comments on becoming Chief Scientist of the RAF: offered post by Chief of the Air Staff Spotswood, despite previous disagreements over procurement of American or British systems; responsibilities of position, research groups at High Wycombe and Singapore; anecdote about applied psychology group at headquarters; details of applied psychology tests. [2:01:56] Remarks on : civil service selection processes, JC not very career minded, but career opportunities coming along; George MacFarlane's return from MINITECH to become CER; reorganisation of chief scientist position due to pressures on manpower;

  • Description

    Interview with aeronautical engineer and government scientist, Sir John Charnley

  • Related transcripts

    Sir John Charnley interviewed by Thomas Lean: full transcript of the interview

  • Related links

    Visit this interviewee's page on the 'Voices of Science' web resource

  • Metadata record:

    View full metadata for this item

Charnley, John (Part 16 of 23)

Please log in to update your playlists.

Can you tell us more about the context of the recording? Or can you share information on its content - timings of key sections or important details? Please add your notes. Uninformative entries may not be retained.

Please log in to leave notes.